I purposely did not ask this question on one of the other threads about RPI, so PLEASE confine any answer/discussion to my actual question, and not how it might favor or "screw" anybody's team:
This is a hyper hypothetical, but assume teams A and B play five teams with the same (and bad) RPI, and 5 others with a strong RPI but clearly team A's is a bit better. Both are undefeated thru 5 games; who would have the higher RPI going in to Week 6?:
Team A:
Game 1- W opponent RPI 30
Game 2- W " " 32
Game 3- W " " 35
Game 4- W " " 27
Game 5- W " " 22
Game 6- Opponent RPI 1
Game 7 " " 2
Game 8 " " 3
Game 9 " " 4
Game 10 " " 5
Team B:
Game 1- W opponent RPI 6
Game 2- W " " 7
Game 3- W " " 8
Game 4- W " " 9
Game 5- W " " 10
Game 6- Opponent RPI 30
Game 7 " " 32
Game 8 " " 35
Game 9 " " 27
Game 10 " " 22
And to further my hype-hypothetical, assume Team A won all of their first 5 gamesagainst weak/mediocre competition by less than 7 points, and Team B won all theirs against strong teams by over 20 points.
I'm going to go ahead and state that my limited knowledge of the RPI process as I've read it on ncpreps is that Team A while clearly the weaker team will have the better RPI going in to Week 6, but if the remainder of the schedule plays out as expected just from looking at on-field results thru the first 5 games and their almost opposite level of competition in their two half-season schedules, the clearly stronger Team B will rise in the RPI and Team A will fall to where by week 10 it all reasonably sorts itself out. Of course, if Team A were to somehow catch fire and both win out, then clearly Team A would have the higher RPI. But again, who would have the higher RPI after week 5?
Again, full disclaimer:
-for entertainment & information purposes only
- your mileage may vary