Good post.
We enjoy these debates.
But we must make a few points.
There is no way for you, us, or anyone else to know how the existence of the WNCHSAA affected the placement of all public programs in their respective classifications. There is a very real possibility that the smallest ADM programs in the WNCHSAA would have been placed in the NCHSAA 1A class, especially over the 48 year period it operated. That included the Great Depression, WW II, the baby boom, and integration.
Also, some of the the largest ADMs in 1A, the NCHSAA may have chosen to move to 2A, if no WNCHSAA.
You do understand that the movement of even a single program into 1A or out of 1A changes history.
The period of Robbinsville Titles, 1965-1976, that you are focused on, did include significant influences of the baby boom and integration on ADMs. There is no way to prove Robbinsville’s Titles would not have been affected.
Research also shows that Bessemer City, eventually a member of the WNCHSAA, played in the 1950 and 1952 NCHSAA 1A Title games.
No way to prove, no way to confirm.
We gave Robbinsville credit in the first post opening this thread.
Robbinsville has the most”unified” class Titles with 7.
Your first 6 Titles came during the existence of the WNCHSAA. Your 2014 and 2019 Titles came as a class subdivision.
Y’all have 15 Championship Titles. Congratulations. That’s a bunch.
But we do have a question. And it is similar to the Reidsville unavoidable blemish.
What happened from the 1992 Title all the way until even your next appearance in 2014?
That’s 21 years. Over 2 decades.
And it goes back to 1983 before that.
1984 to 2013 with one lone appearance and Title. 30 years.
That’s approaching Reidsville’s 1971-2001 absence from even a Title appearance.
You have 15 Titles, but the vast majority came over 40 years ago.
Most of Reidsville’s Titles were over 50 years ago.
Any modern current, relative debate about “most Titles, capital of, etc.” must consider consistency at some point.
As we mentioned before, Princeton is recognized as having the most College Football National Titles.
Shelby won 6 Championship Titles in the WNCHSAA with 10 Appearances.
Shelby has won 12 Championship Titles in the NCHSAA with 17 Appearances, including one Appearance in 1924 before the WNCHSAA was formed and in an early version of the NCHSAA that had no classes.
Shelby also won a Championship Title in 1984 in Division II, what the NCHSAA termed “Other Championships”. Shelby also appeared in the 1983 Division II Championship Title Game.
Division II was explained later as a prelude to the Subclassifications playoff format. The Association was not sure if it would create a playoff system for Conference runner ups or subdivide the classes in two, and open for non-conference champs to qualify. They chose subdivisions.
Some question the inclusion of Division II as a true Championship Title. We do, too.
But you, Robbinsville, certainly include your 1965 Title and it was ONE OF FOUR DIVISIONAL TITLES given in 1A that year. Reidsville counts all 3 of their Western Division Titles as well, 1963, 1969, and 1970. And you both should. It was the playoff format set up by the Association governing body and you won every game you could.
We did too in Division II in 1984.
That Shelby team was 12-1 and gave up 6 points a game.
How far would they have gone in the recent subclass set up? Don’t know.
So, Shelby has 19 State Championship Titles in 29 State Championship Title Game Appearances.
Reidsville has the most titles at 22. But not as many appearances.
And a glaring 31 consecutive, recent year hole within the last 50 years.
Shelby has appeared in, at a minimum, back to back Championship Title Games in each of the last SIX DECADES.
Shelby has won at least one State Championship in each of the last SEVEN DECADES. Most have more than one.
Shelby has the most all-time wins in NC and the most playoff wins of any public high school in the COUNTRY.
The most successful, sustained, winningest high school football program in North Carolina.
The True Dynasty
Our website can fill in any other details.
Www.shelbyhighfootball.com