It's a shame and why I HATE when people say seeding doesn't matter. You can't be too too upset about the 2 out of 3 thing. Shelby just happened to draw the short straw there. Even if Hibriten, Shelby, South Point are 1,2,3 someone was going to be in the same 2 out of 3 situation.
But as a #1 Seed, South Point deserved better than getting a Top 5 team like Shelby in the second round -- and Shelby probably deserved more than just one home playoff game. Not all conferences are created equal, thus not all records can be measured at face value. You want your bracket setup so the best teams meet in the later rounds. NCHSAA needs to find a way to create balance in these brackets.
They did, they went with the power rankings which I think helped. Note, that next year they are going back to the top three teams from each conference make the playoffs regardless of records. Schools with 6-5 records crying about not making the playoffs.
Even by previous years this scenario would have played out. Undefeated conference champions would have drawn straws for place. Second place teams would have been seeded after conference champions by overall record.
I like the power poll with only conference champions being guaranteed a bid. Seed all teams by their power ranking. It could be three teams from one conference as the first three seeded teams. That is what I want but that will not happen because the schools go against it. I call BS!