SimmonsRatings Playoff Bracket Projections
- Thread starter SimmonsRatings
- Start date
No dog here but that is part of what is wrong with new system. Yes I understand that reason for forfeits was a physical form on a player that has been stated did not play in games, only dressed. But facts are facts and games were forfeited.
According to the omnipotent Maxpreps MIC did finish 5th in that Southern Piedmont while TJA is listed at top. Somehow the NCHSAA seeded MIC ahead of TJA. While I do not know, nor have I seen either team, by the letter of the law looks like seeding should have taken into account standings.
OK done sticking my nose in the 1A board for a while. Sorry but you guys have a lot of fun over here.
The new system splitting the brackets up into west, midwest, ect had it's downs but it's a new trial system which we all play in. This is something you should take up for next year. The consistent complaining is pointless now. The west bracket had 3 conf champions and TJ did it to themselves losing to Cherryville. Midwest was weak this year and that's just the luck of the draw. TJ knows what is about to happen so they want to keep hammering the home field stuff. Be happy your in the playoffs and play ball. If you're really the conf champions (home or away) you shouldn't have no problem with the "5th place team" in your conf RIGHT?? Do the same thing that beat that 5th place team the first time.
Last edited:
Matchups are fine and not playing same old teams also good. It is the seeding that many people are having problems with. Whether are not you are at home is often huge in teams that are evenly matched.
Not saying system doesn't have its merits, just saying could be tweeked some. Also think, as I have stated, that in future teams will look to schedule weaker non conference games to better their seeding for playoffs.
Not saying system doesn't have its merits, just saying could be tweeked some. Also think, as I have stated, that in future teams will look to schedule weaker non conference games to better their seeding for playoffs.
Last edited:
I agree but people don't do easiest.
Also might be multiple teams with same record hence they would use I guess the all mighty Maxpreps flawed rankings.
I agree....conference rematches were down to a null almost & should never happen in 1st round and better record should host...NCHSAA should reserve the right to make those changes without appproval of the board....plus figure out how to reduce travel so more fans will go....really don't see many from South Stanly rolling in Friday night but are welcomed as always ( come hungry; have good choices in concession stand)
Why should North Stanly host Swain when Swain came in 2nd in the conference and played a much tougher nonconference schedule? They drew the No. 4 seed in the West, so North Stanly goes to them. And I bet the game will play out Swain winning significantly.
I agree the new system is the best we have seen in awhile and we must give credit to the state for trying.
No perfect system. It seems to be an improvement.
BUT take a look at 4AA...Mallard Creek #5 in MW must play at #4 W Hough, a conference team they beat by 20 points earlier in the year and ahead of in conference play. Weird...huh?
BUT take a look at 4AA...Mallard Creek #5 in MW must play at #4 W Hough, a conference team they beat by 20 points earlier in the year and ahead of in conference play. Weird...huh?
Absoluteley standings should be taken into account when seeding a team. a conference champion shouldn't be going on the road in the second round. It only takes a little common sense to know that. obviously the HSL HAS NONE!!
Not when they are # 5 in the conference. They were suppose to be banned from the playoffs for playing players that didn't have a change of address to be eligible to play. The HSL didn't have the nuts to go thru with it.
It may be what's best for 2a, 3a, and 4a, but the system is not best for 1a. In terms of the location of 1a teams... You have Cherryville traveling to Whiteville for a first round playoff game. This was the state championship game for baseball, but for football its a first round game. Also, and I'm not bashing anyone because it is no teams fault, but in the little 1a, you have teams with losing records hosting playoff games. I just think the 1a should have been left alone due to 64 of the 74 schools making playoffs. 1Vs16, 2vs15 and so forth. We'll see how it all plays out this week though!
A Jacketfan
A Jacketfan
There is no such thing is High School League in the state of NC. Are you (all4usc) from other state previously???
In all reality the 1A teams need to be cut to 48 teams. You would cut out the very bad teams and have better games. Coaches didn't want to do this, but it's impossible to make everyone happy on this because travel is part of playing in the playoffs. I've been with my team from Tabor City to Murphy and all parts in between. Going places we have never been is a fun part.
