Don't know anything about West Caldwell....but according to carolinapreps.com website (who has records of every team in the state from 1960 forward),,,,
1984........Record was 9-3 with a 2nd round playoff loss to Kannapolis
1985........Record was 10-1 with 1st round playoff loss to Forest Hills
1987........Record was 12-2 with a 4th round playoff loss to Shelby