Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
No... Galaviz is the better offensive player but definitely not a better defensive back or all around athlete than Wiley, who had a big year at safety and as a kick/punt returner.Originally posted by knight2014:
How about putting him in over wiley instead..as Cody and Galaviz had a much better year in every way?
I'm aware of all of that, I didn't mean it as a dig at the staff but I can see how it was percieved that way. No need for the "a little more complicated than subbing in Madden" rhetoric.Originally posted by moped master:
I love how fans assume coaches don't thoroughly assess who gets the ball when, how often, and in what capacity. On top of that, take into consideration what combos of personnel it takes to make that happen, game situations, that player's health or development of ability in certain circumstances, what you gain and lose by moving him from a position to another, how it compliments your scheme or makes you vulnerable to being keyed
Having two really good players at one position often hurts on these types of teams as the votes get spread out.Originally posted by Delendo:
Cody Garner and Adrian Whack from Princeton. Best LB duo in 1A.
You've got freedom of speech, so by all means say it how you see it.Originally posted by mbdfan:
I'm aware of all of that, I didn't mean it as a dig at the staff but I can see how it was percieved that way. No need for the "a little more complicated than subbing in Madden" rhetoric.Originally posted by moped master:
I love how fans assume coaches don't thoroughly assess who gets the ball when, how often, and in what capacity. On top of that, take into consideration what combos of personnel it takes to make that happen, game situations, that player's health or development of ability in certain circumstances, what you gain and lose by moving him from a position to another, how it compliments your scheme or makes you vulnerable to being keyed
It's possible to have a differing viewpoint on the involvement of a player and in what capacity. Doesn't necessarily make anyone right or wrong, does it?
He was a standout defensive back, an elite kick and punt returner, a serious big play threat at wide receiver and a great track athlete. Ty would be good at any sporting endeavor he pursued. He's a physical specimen, a truly exceptional athlete.Originally posted by BlackCat93:
And just exactly what is your logic for reasoning for All-Around Athlete MBDfan?
Fair enough. The flip side of that is even those with PHD's can be wrong or make a mistake. I simply feel Ty should've gotten more touches on offense, nothing personal intended.Originally posted by moped masterBut see it this way...If I visit a doctor's office once a week, would I walk out with enough medical knowledge to publicly criticize the doc's decisions?
IMO he deserves all he gets and more.Originally posted by knight2014:
LOL!!! Cruz Galiviz dominated the SMC and playoffs this year. He had over 2,000 yards rushing, 30 plus TD's on offense (wiley?) and 90 plus tackles on defense (wiley?). mbd said"I saw bigger standouts at individuals postions" lol...he had over 300 yards rushing in the first game against murphy and was a big time player on the defense that stopped murphys high scoring offense (miss those games?). If there is a player in the state that deserves the awards that are still coming his way...its Cruz Galiviz! Its silly and sour grapes in the highest degree for a murphy fan to criticize his awards and accomplisments after one of the best seasons in conference history...climaxed by his team going 16-0 and winning a state championship...with him leading the way!!!
Thought I would post his stats in the two murphy wins.
Game 1
3 Cruz Galaviz (Sr) 34 carries 330 yards 9.7 ypc 83 longest 3 td's
3 Cruz Galaviz (Sr) 7 solo tackles 2 assists 9 total tackles
Game 2
3 Cruz Galaviz (Sr) 17 carries 51 yards 3.0 ypc
3 Cruz Galaviz (Sr) 8 solo 3 assists 11 total tackles
This post was edited on 1/14 1:00 PM by knight2014
Nobody criticized anything about his accomplishments or his season. I said he was one of the best all around players Murphy saw this season. The best one just happened to be a different player on the same team (Matheson). So quit picking out parts of my post to make a strawman argument to feel "slighted".Originally posted by knight2014:
Its silly and sour grapes in the highest degree for a murphy fan to criticize his awards and accomplisments